Dor is one of those rare gems in Indian cinema – a film with strong female characters and an engaging story that keeps you hooked right to the end. There are excellent performances from all the cast and the visuals are stunning with beautiful shots of Himachal Pradesh and Rajasthan. It’s a story that contains many aspects of love and friendship, but it also shines a light on the life of women in rural India and the harsh realities of losing the protection of a husband in a patriarchal society.
The film tells the story of Zeenat (Gul Panag) and Meera (Ayesha Takia), two completely different women in matters of personality and culture, and how their lives become intertwined. Despite their many differences the two women also have some commonality as they are both recently married and their husbands have left to work in the Middle East. In the opening scenes, director and writer Nagesh Kukunoor uses similar events in the lives of the two women to illustrate differences in their temperament and situation which rather neatly gives the bare bones of the plot, as well as introducing the characters.
Gul Panag suits the character of Zeenat and perfectly captures her stubborn independence. Zeenat is a Muslim woman from a small town in Himachal Pradesh who is determined to live life on her own terms and maintain her freedom. For example, when her suitor Aamir (Rushad Rana) comes courting Zeenat rejects his advances in favour of repairing her house – personally I would have put him to work! This down-to-earth practicality and lack of sentimentality is repeated throughout the film which has the effect of making the few romantic moments much sweeter as a result of their rarity.
Despite her independent nature, Zeenat does love Aamir and when word comes that he has been detained in prison for the suspected crime of killing his room-mate, she immediately springs to his defence. Zeenat is convinced that the death must have been an accident and is dismayed to learn that Aamir has been sentenced to death unless she can obtain a pardon from the wife of the dead man. Zeenat has a close relationship with the local Imam and takes his advice on how to track down the young woman who may be the means to Aamir’s freedom.
Although she doesn’t know anything about the woman’s whereabouts, Zeenat heads off to Rajasthan with a small bag, a photograph of the two men and a huge amount of determination and optimism. Her faith in the universe seems to be answered when she meets up with a Behroopiya (Shreyas Talpade) despite the fact that at their first meeting he tricks and robs her. However it is the Behroopiya who does manage to lead her in the right direction to find Meera.
Throughout the opening scenes with Zeenat, we are also introduced to Meena and her very different outlook on life. Meera is happily married to Shankar (Anirudh Jaykar) and has no problems living within the confines of a strictly traditional family in Rajasthan. Ayesha Takia portrays Meena as young and innocent, flirting as she dances joyously for her husband, and becoming upset that he is leaving to work abroad. Her youth is also shown in her pride that it is her husband who is earning the money which will buy back the family’s ancestral home. However as the story progresses and Meena finds out that Shankar has been killed, she exhibits maturity along with strength and resilience as her world crumbles around her.
Ayesha Takia is very impressive in a role that demands her character go through a major upheaval in her life and cope with the aftermath. She makes the transition from young wife to virtual living non-entity as a widow very naturally and brings out every emotion as Meera has to deal with her new status in life. Her reaction to the suitcase of her husbands clothes is perfectly nuanced and her moments of joy as she discovers friendship are beautifully acted. It’s not surprising that she won a number of awards for her performance here. One of my favourite moments is when she dances in the desert with Zeenat and the Behroopiyah – perfect!
Although at times the contrasts between the two women seems a little too contrived, for the most part the juxtaposition of their different lives works well. The grief and devastation shown by Meera for the double blows of the death of her husband and her loss of freedom is realistically portrayed while Zeenat’s self-contained grief is tempered with her determination and drive to save her husband at all costs. Both actors seem very well suited to their roles, and Shreyas Talpede adds just the right amount of comic relief as the Behroopiya. This character appears to be some kind of a guardian angel or possibly just an embodiment of Zeenat’s subconscious, as he watches over Zeenat and gives her advice. It’s effective, especially when added into the more dream-like landscape of Rajasthan.
There is one misstep in the film with the director playing a sleazy businessman who is renting the house in Rajasthan. His repellent suggestion to Meera’s father in law feels filmi and false compared to the rest of the screenplay, although otherwise both Girish Karnad and Prateeksha Lonkar are excellent in the roles of Meera’s in-laws.
The background score by Salim – Sulaiman Merchant is beautiful and although there are no song and dance numbers the dancing within the film is spontaneous and just wonderful. This is another excellent song which shows Zeenat’s journey from Himachal Pradesh along with Meera’s symbolic journey from wife to widow.
Although not credited, Dor is based on a Malayalam film Perumazhakkalam which perhaps explains the quality of the story. I’m still trying to track down a copy of this original film with English subtitles as it also won numerous awards and I’d like to compare the two. However, Dor is still an enchanting film and the two leads ensure that the quality of the acting is as impressive as the screenplay and Sudeep Chatterjee’s gorgeous cinematography. Although there is an underlying theme relating to the plight of women and their lack of value in some parts of India, it’s counterbalanced by Zeenat’s fierce independence and fighting spirit, so Dor never feels too preachy or morally worthy. it’s a simple tale, beautifully told and I thoroughly recommend it. 4 ½ stars.
As you rightly mentioned, Dor is the unofficial remake of the hard hitting malayalam film Perumazhakalam(Monsoon) directed by Kamal. The movie was based in a real life incident & had a heavy star cast. You should be able to watch the movie online as its quite old.
As far as women centric movies go, there are quite a few in Malayalam like Panchagni, Manichitrathazhu & a few more.
Thanks – Perumazhakalam is on Youtube, but unfortunately not with subtitles. Since the dialogue is so important in Dor, I really want to wait until I can find a subtitled copy, especially since I know it is a little different from the remake.
I’ve seen Manichitrathazhu – actually I’ve written it up on here too https://cinemachaat.com/2011/12/04/manichitrathazhu/
Thanks for the other recommendation 🙂
So glad to see you review Dor – I also just watched it for the first time, and loved it! It’s such a beautiful and understated yet satisfying movie. It’s become one that I try to get as many people as possible to watch.
I also really wish I could see what happens after the final scene. I would willingly watch several more hours of these women’s lives!
Thanks for your comment. I agree! It would be interesting to see what happened next 🙂
Especially when Aamir came home – I wonder how Meera would cope? Or perhaps she would already have moved on by then – so many possibilities!
Watch Nagesh Kukunoor’s Hyderabad Blues 1 & 2 and Iqbal – Shreyas did very well in Iqbal
Thanks for the recommendations. I have Hyderabad Blues and Iqbal in the pile to watch – hopefully soon 🙂
All the reviews mention how good Shreyas was in Iqbal, so I really must move it up the pile! Have you seen any of Nagesh Kukunoor’s more recent films? Mostly they don’t seem to have done as well, despite (or perhaps because of) the bigger name cast such as John Abraham and Akshay Kumar. I haven’t seen them any of these as none of them sounded particularly inspiring!
Yes I did see the John Abraham one, can’t remember the name now – was quite good though the subject was a serious one. I haven’t seen the one with Akshay Kumar.
Dor was excellent. I too found that particular incident and scene of Nagesh’s personal appearance contrived in Dor and not fitting into the movie at all. Somewhere in my archives I have saved a copy of an interview with Nagesh K on Dor – will pass it on when I find it.
Hyderbad Blues 2 was good. Unfortunately I was not able to find a copy of Hyderabad Blues1 which I believe was Nagesh’s first movie. I personally liked Iqbal and Shreyas indeed did a good job